[BadVista Advocate] UK Becta recommending ODF/avoiding OOXML and Vista "not recommended"
Fred Okuma
fred.k at ieee.org
Sun Jan 27 07:57:31 EST 2008
A little bit off-topic now, but Becta gave one
good reason in their report to recommend 'open
software' in educational environment.
My summary:
- Some say students should be familiar with
'industry standard' software (meaning Microsoft
Office).
- Not true. Students are now highly computer
literate. They can use many types of applications.
- Multi-vendor skill sets should enhance
employability in the 21st century, not limit it.
Excerpt from the report follows. Becta recommends
'freely available software' instead of so-called
'industry standard software' in it (
http://publications.becta.org.uk/download.cfm?resID=35275
):
---- quote ----
Addressing issues of mind set
6.12
Some schools and colleges take the view that they
need to use a specific proprietary software
product because that product is widely used in
industry and commerce, and, the argument goes,
students need to be familiar with what is in the
real world ¹.
...(snip)...
6.13
However, students today are usually highly ICT
literate, and are likely to use a wide range of
ICT software in school or college possibly even
a wider range at home. They can also happily
switch from using computers at school to those at
home or in the local library or internet café.
They would be very unlikely to be incapable of
using a particular version of an office
productivity suite when they left school because
they had become used to using (say)
OpenOffice.org at school.
6.14
In summary, the familiarity ¹ argument is more
suited to pupils of the 1980s and 1990s than to
those of the 21st century. Indeed it would be a
poor testament to today ¹s ICT education if, on
leaving formal education, young people were
unable to use a basic software package (such as
office productivity software or a web
browser)just because it had some differences in
functionality, or in its user interface, from the
one they had used at school or college.
Multi-vendor skill sets should enhance
employability in the 21st century, not limit it.
---- end quote ----
Fred
More information about the Advocate
mailing list