[BadVista Advocate] Ubuntu?

[Lam YongXian]

> John Sullivan wrote:
>> So while people "on the ground" might help other people switch away from
>> Vista
>> by installing a variety of distributions, let's keep the official
>> message of
>> the campaign clear by only recommending the fully free ones like
>> gNewSense.
>
> I find the question whether binary drivers are okay or not extremely
> difficult to answer. When I switched to GNU/Linux a few years ago, I
> didn't think about it twice when I installed the nVidia driver, Flash,
> RealPlayer, VMWare with Windows on it, ... It just helped me make the
> switch, and I didn't know any better.
>
> A few years and what must have been hundreds of Stallman essays later, I'm
> using only free software, and I try to advocate it in this way.
>
> Still, I don't feel bad about recommending Ubuntu to new GNU/Linux users.
> The thing is, they wouldn't switch if, say, they can't use the Internet
> anymore because their wi-fi device isn't supported. Once I have a chance
> to tell them about the issue, they'll even know why they should buy a
> different wi-fi device next time. But in the meantime, none of us would
> tell these people, "Bad luck. No GNU for you, you loooser!"
>
> So, in my opinion, it's not evil to recommend Ubuntu. Ubuntu isn't evil.
> Users who can't (yet) do without  proprietary software aren't evil.
>
>
> But exactly *because* this question has no easy answer (except the
> dogmatic ones), and there are so many gray areas, promoting only free
> distributions isn't only the *right* thing to do, it's also the *easiest*
> way to go. Otherwise, we'd find it extremely difficult to settle on a
> common definition of what is and is not acceptable.
>
> Anyway, I don't consider it a particularly strong message to say, "Don't
> use proprietary Vista. Use GNU/Linux, we have proprietary drivers too."
>
> Kind Regards,
> M.F.
>
>
>
>
>
> __________________________________________________
> Do You Yahoo!?
> Tired of spam?  Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around
> http://mail.yahoo.com
>
> _______________________________________________
> Advocate mailing list
> Advocate at badvista.org
> http://badvista.fsf.org/mailman/listinfo/advocate
>

A 2 step switch can be useful.

Proprietary -> Open Source -> Free Software

One way is to concentrate free software promotion on the Open Source
community, while letting that community do the job of making proprietary
user switch to them first.

BadVista campaign seems to be trying to offer a direct switch (Proprietary
-> Free Software), or if its too hard for people, at least help the first
switch (Proprietary -> Open Source).

We just have to remember, our root, the ultimate goal is free software.

---
Lam YongXian
Adolflam.com

FSF member #5279